With election
season upon us here in the US, public discourse shops among clichés and platitudes about
candidates’ likely actions if elected, bolstering blind faith that government serves
the public interest and upholds the Constitution & Bill of Rights. In this light,
consider a pair of songs from Devo’s "breakthrough" 1980 album Freedom
of Choice: the title song and "Gates of Steel." They offer pithy insights
into perennial conflicts between liberty and submission, natural rights and oppression,
freedom to choose and fear of responsibility.
The Land of the Free…
If a song exhorts listeners to use their freedom
of choice, ostensibly the writer believes in some significant way people are failing or
refusing to do so. "Freedom of Choice" suggests the writers/performers perceive
that causes their fellow Americans -- "in the land of the free" -- some needless
suffering.
The mysterious opening lines, "Victim of
collision on the open sea / Nobody ever said that life was free," suggest life’s
aquatic origins when there was no tyranny and hence no concept of freedom and life &
death choices that can arise without warning, seemingly for no reason, when how we choose,
not circumstances alone, will determine our fate. Evolution produced a human animal
subject to circumstance, capable of exercising reason, and subject to reflexive emotional
reaction circumventing reason. "Use your freedom of choice, freedom of choice":
Leave the outcome of events to chance, and you’ll drown.
That is particularly important in "the land
of the free," whose Founders recognized that manifesting reason for the common good
in our unique ways, free from tyranny, could result in a shining city on a hill, a society
such as had never existed in all of human history, which they understood as a long
succession of tyrannical, violent, and oppressive regimes with a few short-lived
exceptions that proved the rule.
…and Home of… Pavlov’s dogs?
A professor tells me the "poem in ancient
Rome / About a dog who found two bones" might literally refer to a poem by Phaedrus,
the Roman Aesop, in which a dog, swimming and carrying a bone in his mouth, sees himself
cum treat reflected on the water’s surface. Lunging to seize what he takes to be a
bone in another dog’s mouth, he loses the bone he’s already got. The
treat-triggered action reminds us, too, of "Pavlov’s dogs," famous for
demonstrating in their namesake’s experiments how easily humans can condition their
"best friend" to salivate at anything associated with receiving a treat. The
repeated lines "I say it again in the land of the free / Use your freedom of choice,
freedom of choice" tell us we resemble the dog in the poem more than people at
liberty to create the world they desire. "He went in circles / Till he dropped
dead": This particular variation on the theme warns us our misbehavior might have
serious consequences.
Three years before Freedom of Choice, in
his book Snap, Crackle, and Popular Taste: The Illusion of Free Choice in America,
author Jeffrey Schrank described choices between brands of advertised products as
pseudo-choices, illusory non-choices presented as important rather than meaningful choices
on which to base an intelligent life. A meaningful choice might be to read, converse, or
exercise rather than to shop, but advertising and public relations had conditioned
millions of people to think they should give high priority to comparing brands of
mouthwash equally ineffective or frozen chemical food-like concoctions equally devoid of
nutrients.
Focusing and spending wastefully on what is
inconsequential, useless or harmful, we fail to observe and respond to the growth of
corporate tyranny with government support or sanction. Even music becomes a conditioning
device, manipulating our emotions in stores, boutiques, and malls, sometimes on streets
and boardwalks. Our Devo friends needn’t have read Schrank or seen any of the
multitude of books, articles or TV shows about those trends in order to create
"Freedom of Choice" -- the evidence, the behavior is everywhere, always;
that’s why many people don’t notice it.
The song doesn’t tell listeners to share the
writers’/performers’ opinions or tastes, just to recognize reality and exercise
reason rather than spend one’s life duped, pursuing trivial stuff, going in circles
till we drop dead.
What’s in the way?
"Gates of Steel" comes immediately
after "Freedom of Choice" on the album. In addition to having structurally
parallel titles, both songs exhort listeners to do a basic human task. If
"Freedom" tells us to use our freedom or lose it, "Gates" tells us to
tear down artificial barriers between our oppressed, conformist selves and the inner human
voice that comes down to us through the ages: "Unlock the secret voice / Give in to
ancient noise." Both songs, like much of the band’s other material -- and its
satirical uniform costumes, album covers, stage acts, and videos -- mock groupthink, herd
mentality, arbitrary conformity beyond reason.
Steel is a product of many thousands of years of
technological development and affluence -- the flow of Earth’s wealth to humans --
and centuries of growth of corporations -- nonhuman, nonliving, non-feeling
wealth-accumulating fictitious persons as they are called in law. But "A man
is real / Not made of steel"! Human beings can’t fulfill their needs and their
biological nature when they adopt a nonhuman, corporate mode of existence, suppressing as
if with a steel barrier their original humanity -- "Half a goon and half a god."
Superman, the Man of Steel, comes to mind, the
superhero whose presence and popularity soared in the era when the members of Devo grew
up. After World War II, millions returned home from the horrors of war, took factory and
corporate-management jobs, and suppressed their natural responses to what they had
experienced. Drinking, building, motoring about, watching movies & TV, vacationing,
and fitting in, they deadened themselves emotionally and spiritually. Post-traumatic
stress disorder, common in war survivors, wasn’t recognized then. Sucking everything
up to move forward, many must have found it comforting -- and helpful in relations with
their children -- to be mythologized as the invulnerable, emotionless Man of Steel who
never fails to rescue those threatened by evil as they and their slain comrades had helped
to do in Europe and the Pacific.
Breaking free
The members of Devo grew up in the war economy
that still has never ceased growing for long since World War II. Akron, where the band
originates, was a longtime tire-manufacturing town -- hence the epithet "those rubber
brains from Akron" a writer foisted on the "spud boys," as they preferred
satirically to call themselves referring to potatoes’ blandness, plainness, and
combination of superficial difference & internal sameness. Not war survivors
themselves but art students, they found value in exploring, not suppressing, their
humanity. And even the military general their parents’ and grandparents’
generations made president had warned of an out-of-hand military-industrial complex.
Whereas "Freedom of Choice" warns us
that if we don’t exercise our freedom to choose meaningfully we’ll behave like
the unreasoning dog who goes in circles till he drops dead, "Gates of Steel"
tells us to break down artificial obstacles to our knowing and communicating what we want
and need. "A man is real / That’s how he feels"! He not only feels as if
he is real; he feels by virtue of being real -- a biological being, not a
manufactured material or product.
Apes of the planet
But what kind of biological being is a real,
non-corporate, non-metal human being? Some kind of agitated, unsatisfiable ape, perhaps.
"The ape regards his tail / He stepped on it"? Some versions say "He’s
stuck on it," but the vocals in the recording clearly say "stepped." And it
would be hard to make sense of comparing humans with an ape "stuck on" his tail,
since apes don’t have tails. The lyric I find most likely to be the actual one
suggests monkeys -- with tails -- preceded apes in evolution and quips that apes lost
their tails by stepping on them rather than through the evolutionary process where they
began living on the ground, no longer grasping tree branches with tails. It’s through
stupidity, not sapience as our species’ current Latin name Homo sapiens has
it, that we got the way we are -- which, as we’ll see in a moment, Devo’s
songsmiths see as regression, not progress.
"The Earth it moves too slow / We pay to
play the human way": Apes’ and therefore humans’ eagerness to have things
otherwise than nature alone provides for led to our early ancestors’ speeding up
their own evolution, eventually creating civilization -- and suffering from the
consequences, by suppressing their humanity with artificial barriers for unfulfilling
purposes. "But the Earth is all we know" -- we want life to be richer, safer,
more enjoyable than nature allows, but pursuing a better existence makes us unhappy due to
our biologically determined emotional and spiritual nature, rooted in Earth, not in stuff
like steel that we make from parts of it. To be fulfilled, we must recognize we are
"real" and "give in to ancient noise," "Take a chance [on?] a
brand new dance" -- stop dancing to the corporate tune and dance to the "secret
voice," the sound of the human soul: Do the dance that expresses the truth within.
Fromm revisited
One of the most influential books of pre-Devo
decades is Escape from Freedom by Erich Fromm, first published in 1941. Like
some others, Fromm sought to explain the popular appeal of fascism and Nazism. In a
Western world of democratic principles and opportunities, why do millions of people accept
or embrace dictators aligned with a plutocracy and non-living, non-feeling
corporations’ interests, against individual rights and the public interest? Why would
a species that evolved free on the savanna have lived so long under tyranny before
creating legal and constitutional rights and democratic societies, then subvert them?
Fromm posited that large numbers of people
don’t want the responsibility, uncertainty, constant vigilance, and fear that come
with freedom, so we welcome those who will assume responsibility for everything, enabling
us to go about our daily lives without inconvenient abiding worries and moral burdens.
Primates’ natural social groups consist of
extended family units including individuals who leave their original groups to find mates,
preventing too much inbreeding and maintaining hybrid vigor. Hierarchies understood by all
group members prevent chaos and enable those best at nurturing and protecting the group to
thrive and reproduce the most. Dominant individuals who perpetuate injustice are
immediately punished and sometimes supplanted. Apart from observable preferred treatment
in food, sex, and a few other basics, dominant individuals lead the same lives as the
rest, and competition for dominance is open to all who might choose to risk the
consequences.
As human societies departed from their original
ecological niche, created agriculture, civilization, and eventually mass societies,
dominant individuals made themselves and their progeny ever less vulnerable to retribution
or challenge, and everyone else found themselves in increasingly confusing, oppressive,
and entrenched social, political, and economic systems. Meritocracy gave way to arbitrary
power and tyranny, with most people living abject lives as slaves in one form or another.
No wonder so many people want simple instructions, "role models" to follow, a
concept of a "mainstream" to be a part of -- notions unknown to the Founders and
not included in the Constitution.
Will we get fooled again?
Devo named itself and based its work not just on
a musical concept but on a sociopolitical one: "de-evolution" -- as the official
Devo website puts it, "the idea that instead of evolving, mankind has actually
regressed, as evidenced by the dysfunction and herd mentality of American society."
Often misunderstood as promoting this mentality and thereby a tendency toward fascism,
Devo in fact satirizes de-evolution, groupthink, conformity, needless surrender to
authority. Satire involves adopting the persona of the subject of one’s comment. At
its most successful, it simultaneously exposes and sympathizes, as compared to merely
ridiculing or lambasting.
The band’s trademark mock-robotic
instrumentation, vocals, costumes & other visuals, and stage movements lead
superficial listeners to think the band sincerely promotes what it in fact satirizes. The
seriousness of Mark Mothersbaugh and Gerald V. Casale’s lyrics is comedic, comedy in
the true sense being serious entertainment. (Susan A. Schmidt and Deborah L. Smith also
co-wrote "Gates Of Steel," according to the band’s official website but not
according to some other sources.)
In establishing individual liberty and equal
rights under the law as the bases of the US Constitution, the Founders sought to create a
path to a shining city on a hill, not shiny vehicles and potato-chip bags. The market met
basic needs as described in The Wealth of Nations, published the same year as the
Declaration of Independence and Common Sense. Consumerism wasn’t a way of
life, nor shopping an all-day amusement or fetish. By going from one distraction to
another like "a dog who found two bones," we surrender our freedom to choose
among things that matter and find ourselves gated off from our true selves, which are
partly political.
The Constitution authorizes every citizen to
exercise meaningful choices, but as Ralph Nader points out, Republicans and Democrats are
very often the same wine in different bottles when it comes to sanctioning corporate
rights eschewed by the Founders and precluded by the Constitution. With John McCain and
Barack Obama vying for the presidency in a society where public discourse has largely
devolved into television ads and mass-media distortions of candidates and their records as
well as of the Constitution and the law -- all funded by non-living, non-feeling,
non-thinking corporations -- time will tell whether we use our freedom of choice and twist
away the gates of steel or submit to those paying to determine what we think about and
languish behind barriers we choose not to recognize, let alone twist away.
...David J. Cantor
davidc@soundstage.com
