November 2008
This sprawling piece is perhaps longer than it needs to be, and is not burdened by an excess of subtlety -- but it is clearly from the heart, and is a valuable document of its time. McKay conducted the premiere, in 1935, at the University of Washington in Seattle, where he taught. Naxoss revival makes good use of the very capable and committed forces of the University of Kentucky in Lexington, under a conductor who understands the scores strengths and limitations. The sound quality is well tailored to the musical content, and the documentation, by the composers sons, is authoritative and detailed (though some editing might have been helpful). In sum: an intriguing bit of American musical history, and if it provokes some curiosity about the more modestly proportioned McKay works on the earlier CDs, so much the better. GO BACK TO: |