[SoundStage!]Home Audio
Equipment Review
January 2001

PS Audio Power Plant P600 Power Regenerator

by Tom Lyle

Reviewers' Choice Logo
"[The P600] made my entire
system sound better and brought
out the best in each of the
components it powered."

 

 

 

Review Summary
Sound "The Power Plant P600 improved every sonic parameter," but what Tom first noticed with the P600 in his system was "the complete lack of any background noise -- grounding problems were a thing of the past too."
Features Offers over three times the power of the P300, so it can also provide juice to power amps; calling MultiWave an "option" is a "misnomer" because it "improves the sound to such a degree that [Tom] couldn’t imagine buying the P600 without it."
Use Large size makes finding a place for it somewhat of a challenge; doesn't generate the heat of the P300.
Value "The Power Plant P600 is the best audio accessory I’ve ever had in my system -- although it is an accessory in my system no longer, but rather an integral part of the entire chain that I can no longer do without."

Many consider AC-line treatments a mandatory part of a high-resolution audio/video system. There is also a small but vocal contingent that considers them nothing but snake oil, marketed and manufactured to take advantage of gullible audiophiles. Whether you consider yourself a member of the later or the former may depend on a couple of things. First, for a small (and very lucky) number of audiophiles, these treatments may make no difference to the sound of their systems. This is probably because these audiophiles' listening rooms are located in the middle of nowhere (or they can see it from where they live). The power supplied to the home, one of only a few in the area, is likely as close to pure as possible. Alternatively, and unfortunately for the majority of the rest of us, our listening rooms are located in a populated area where the power is likely to be anything but pure. A positive difference in sound when using a power-line treatment will likely be heard. I’m afraid I’m one of the unlucky ones who live in an area that's not the best for good sound.

Although those living in an urban high-rise might be worse off than what I have to deal with as far as AC power is concerned, the juice supplied to my home is pretty bad. I’m one mile outside of a major metropolitan area and in a very populous suburb. There are many broadcast towers, some closer than a half mile away, one being used by a 50,000-watt FM station. Overhead lines on telephone poles carry cable TV, electrical power, telephone, and who knows what else. Retail, industry, and large apartment complexes are close by, and the subway station is blocks away. During the day, and especially during the summer months, it seems like my system’s sound is degraded to the fidelity of a portable AM radio. At night things get better, but only after 9:00 PM does the system reach what I used to think was its full potential.

I tried power conditioners -- from Chang Lightspeed, Tice, MIT, Blue Circle, and many others. The ones that worked best in my system were those from MIT and Chang. These definitely made a difference -- but there was still a noticeable difference between the sound of the system in the day and at night. I investigated other options, including generators, battery power, and some other large transformer installations. All were prohibitively expensive -- and none were guaranteed to work.

Last year I was doubly blessed. In October our daughter was born -- my toothless angel. About the same time, PS Audio introduced the first model of their Power Plant line, the P300. This is not a power condition like the models I previously auditioned, but a power regenerator that synthesizes pure AC power. Although it only had enough power capacity to handle the front-end of my system, at last my system was becoming more listenable. With our daughter now sharing our residence, my late-night listening sessions had to be performed during the daylight hours. This was only made possible when using the Power Plant P300. Yet there was still that last bit of frequency extension, smoothness, and detail missing that were only present at night. The only way I was going to get this resolution was by supplying pure AC to the entire system, including the power amp. PS Audio answered my prayers with the introduction of the P600. Finally.

How does it work?

For a much more complete technical explanation of how the Power Plant does the voodoo it does, I suggest visiting PS Audio’s website or reading the SoundStage! review of the P300. But in short, the P600 is a 600-watt AC power generator that produces new AC line voltage. The Power Plant provides surge protection and is fully regulated -- so no matter how low or high your voltage supplied by the power company, the P600 provides 120 (or 220, as required) volts AC. It accepts the AC wall voltage in either 120 or 220 volts AC, steps this up (domestic) or down (foreign) to 143 volts AC, and then steps up or down through the use of a balanced transformer. The AC voltage then passes through a 50-amp diode bridge for rectification, and is then filtered by a bank of 3300mF 100-volt capacitors. This forms the DC power supply. This power supply produces 130 volts DC and is applied to two power-amplification stages. These class-AB stages are fed by a sinewave oscillator, which has an input frequency selected via a front-panel control. There is also the MultiWave option to use a mixture of frequencies, and thus improve the power produced even further. The pure 120 or 220 VAC is fed to eight hospital-grade AC outlets. There is an IEC AC input so you may use a choice of (non-filtering) AC power cords, and there is a binding post for a separate ground.

With everything connected to the P600 Power Plant, the total current requirements of all units combined cannot exceed 720 watts. The P600 is capable of up to 1000 watts for brief periods of time, allowing you to connect reasonably large power amps. I connected all my equipment, other than the powered subwoofer, with no problems whatsoever.

Use

Most complaints regarding the P300, the P600’s older sibling, were the heat the unit generated and its odd shape. The P300 is not very wide, but at 20.5" long, it is deeper than many racks. Plus the heat it generates prevents it from being placed on most racks anyway because the shelves would have to be spaced far apart enough for sufficient ventilation. The P600 doesn’t generate nearly as much heat because the much larger sides are basically the unit’s heat sinks.

But by any reasonable standards, the Power Plant P600 is heavy and huge. It weighs 90 pounds (the 220-volt model weighs 15 more), is 17"W, 9"H, and 19.4" D. I had quite a time unpacking the unit, lugging it across the listening room, and positioning it in an adequate location. Again, it didn’t generate all that much heat -- I left it powered 24 hours a day and it never became more than very warm to the touch. I tried to give it as much breathing room as possible, although it wasn’t as much of a concern as with the space-heater-like character of the P300. I connected every piece of my two-channel system to the P600. Even though the manual states that the P600 shouldn’t be used for power amps greater than 200Wpc, PS Audio assured me that the 250Wpc Krell KAV-250 I own should pose no problem. I connected the sub for just a short time, but the noise coming from its internal amp let me know that this wasn’t such a good idea, so instead I hooked it up to a Chang Lightspeed power conditioner.

The front panel of the P600 has four push-button switches: Power, Mode, select up, and select down. There is also a master power switch on the rear panel that I rarely used. The mode switch activates the front-panel display, which indicates the number of watts produced by the Power Plant.

Because the select up/down switches control its use, it’s important that I discuss the MultiWave option of the Power Plant. But calling this function an "option," to me, is a misnomer. The MultiWave function improves the sound to such a degree that I couldn’t imagine buying the P600 without it. Basically, instead of using a single sinewave, MultiWave uses simultaneous multiple waveforms to feed a power supply. So besides choosing between the 20 frequency settings of the single sinewave, the select up/down buttons choose between ten types of MultiWave patterns. PS Audio has positioned each MultiWave waveform on the menu according to the company's belief in its effectiveness -- the one that PS Audio believes to be the best is first, the second best is second, and so on. I found that the first and fifth sounded the best, and some selected made the sound worse -- but none was as bad as using no Power Plant at all! And almost all sounded better than the non-MultiWave setting.

Associated Equipment

Loudspeakers – Legacy Classic, PSB Stratus Mini, Velodyne HGS-15b subwoofer.

Amplifiers – Krell KAV-250a, Muse Model 150 monoblocks.

Preamplifiers – Audible Illusions Modulus 3A.

Analog – Heavily modified Oracle Delphi turntable, Wheaton Triplaner VI tonearm (with Discovery Cable wired directly to preamp), Benz-Micro H2.O and Lyra Clavis DC phono cartridges, Klyne SK-2 moving-coil preamplifier (when using Clavis cartridge with C-J preamp).

Digital – Meridian 263 DAC, Meridian 200 transport, Pioneer DV-525 DVD player (used as transport), AH! Tjoeb 99 CD player (used as either CD player or transport) Perpetual Technologies P-3A DAC and P-1A digital correction engine, Monolithic Sound P3 Perpetual Power Plant power supply.

Tuner – Magnum-Dynalab FT-101a, NAD 4155.

Interconnects, digital cable and speaker cables – Cardas Quadlink 5 interconnects; MIT 330-plus and Terminator 2 interconnects; MIT Terminator 3 digital cable; MIT Terminator 2 bi-wire speaker cables.

Accessories – Sennheiser HD-600 headphones, Headroom Little More Power headphone amp, PS Audio P300 Power Plant (for front-end), Chang Lightspeed ISO9300 power conditioner, MIT Z-Cord II power cable, Target TT5-sa equipment rack, German Acoustics cones (under digital), 2" concrete slab (under analog), LAST stylus cleaner and Stylast stylus treatment, Record Doctor II record-cleaning machine, Record Research Vinyl Wash and home-brew record-cleaning fluids.

Even with the MultiWave option installed, you can still use the standard single waveform. The select up/down switches will choose which frequency, in 20 steps from 50Hz to 120Hz the Power Plant will generate rather than the 60Hz (or 50Hz foreign) the wall current generates. Some of these frequencies will work better than others at powering different types of equipment, and there are sonic tradeoffs that have to be made with each frequency chosen. Some improved the treble but sacrificed midrange clarity; some improved the mids, some the bass. I found a frequency of 90Hz the best overall, but your mileage may vary.

Another nice feature of the MultiWave upgrade is the ability to alter the voltage that is supplied to the equipment. Although I ended up using the standard 117 VAC, I tried a voltage as high as 121 VAC with varying results.

The "sound"

I hesitate calling what the Power Plant did to my system as imparting a particular sound. When I investigated different standard power conditioners, I found that all improved the sound of the system in one way or another, but all had a certain personality. One unit would make the system sound brighter than the other would; one would impart a burnished character, while another would make the bass sound a bit thick. And none of them would allay the problem I had of the system sounding better at night than in the daytime.

But the Power Plant P600 changed this. It just made my entire system sound better and brought out the best in each of the components it powered. When switching components for review or other types of experimentation, their individual characteristics were much more pronounced when using the P600. That’s it. I could waste some serious space writing about the system’s increased frequency extension, deeper and wider soundstage, better low-level retrieval, and more natural sound. But what I first noticed with the Power Plant P600 in the system was the complete lack of any background noise -- grounding problems were a thing of the past too. There was no more need to lift grounds or perform any other types of fixes. Plus, I’m lucky that my turntable uses a DC motor, so I was also able to power it with the P600. From that point on, the ground connection didn’t make much of a sonic difference -- whether it was attached to the preamp or not. Across-the-board improvements were evident in my entire system, and discussing each would only turn this review into a primer on audiophile sound. Should I cite specific musical examples? That, too, would be a waste of time, for the choice of program material mattered not at all. The Power Plant P600 improved every sonic parameter.

And the difference between how the system sounded in the daytime versus at night? None that I could perceive, and probably none that could be measured either. Because the pure AC generated was just that, it did not vary, regardless of the time of day or what equipment was plugged into the P600 or what type of music I played.

Adding MultiWave to your Power Plant

PS Audio's line of Power Plant power regenerators has burst on the audio scene like a searing guitar chord. But in addition to new Power Plant models, PS Audio has also introduced the MultiWave feature, which can be added to a newly purchased Power Plant for $200 or one that's previously owned for $250.

I own a non-MultiWave Power Plant P300 and really like it, but the audiophile in me was intrigued by the potential sonic improvement by the MultiWave upgrade. So I asked PS Audio to send me the upgrade kit, which they did after meeting high consumer demand. The MultiWave kit consists of a new oscillator card and microprocessor chip, a chip puller, and very detailed directions with pictures. PS Audio also supplies a postage-paid mailer for return of the non-MultiWave parts; what would you do with them otherwise?

Installing the upgrade kit is a snap as it really only requires that I remove the P300's bottom plate and swap out the oscillator card and microprocessor chip, which took all of ten minutes. PS Audio's directions are much more detailed than my description of the process, however, and should be followed to the letter.

Once the MultiWave upgrade was installed, my P300 gained two new menus: one for adjustment of voltage and another for the new and complex waveforms the P300 could now create. With the MultiWave upgrade, you have a choice of nine waveform combinations, and it's easy to hear the differences among them -- and not just in regard to the music emanating from the speakers. The various MultiWaves also changed the sounds coming from the power supply of the Lamm L2 preamp here for review, so I knew the P300 was certainly doing something to the power it produced.

In terms of sound, however, MultiWave is a success. I settled on MultiWave 2, labeled "PS2" on the LED display, as the favorite with my system. At first I thought the leading edge of transients sounded overly emphasized, but this quickly melted away as I realized that the fine noise that was masking such sonic features was greatly reduced. Music sounded clearer and more extended on top with the MultiWave board installed, and the midrange was also more pure, voices sounding even more natural, which is my system's personality in spades. And the best thing about these improvements is universal -- every CD sounds better.

Bottom line: If you own a PS Audio Power Plant, you should add the MultiWave functionality. I can think of no sonic reason not to.

...Marc Mickelson
marc@soundstage.com

Comparisons

Comparisons to what? I already touched upon the inability of standard power conditioners to "repair" faulty AC provided by the electric company. Yes, they can filter the electricity and perform other ways to clean up the filthy current supplied. But they don’t correct voltage dips or surges. They can protect your valuable electronics against the deleterious effects of these anomalies, but correct these anomalies? Forget it. And forget about changing the frequency of the power. I guess if I did install some sort of battery or power generator in my home, I could compare it to them, but…

Some very expensive gear uses the type of power supplies that achieve what the Power Plant does to the AC; that is, they convert to DC and back to pure AC before going to the component’s main power supply. But I did not have any of that equipment on hand to try, and I don’t know if I ever will. Suffice to say the Power Plant P600 is the best audio accessory I’ve ever had in my system -- although it is an accessory in my system no longer, but rather an integral part of the entire chain that I can no longer do without.

Problems?

The only problems I encountered with the P600 were probably caused by me using a power amp slightly above the recommended maximum power. When turning on the power to the amp the surge would cause the preamp to go into stand-by mode. But this wasn't difficult to prevent -- I simply turned on the power to the amp before that to the preamp, and the preamp’s protective standby circuit, which is activated for about a minute, prevented any "thud" from coming through the speakers. Also, I once turned on the Power Plant with the power switches to the connected components in their "on" positions. This caused the P600 to shut down. After about a half-hour rest with its power cord removed, I re-powered the P600 (with the equipment off!) and it operated perfectly.

I used some equipment that didn’t have a power switch, such as a DAC and headphone amp. They drew so little power that it didn’t seem to matter if the Power Plant was powered up with those units already on. But in regular use, I left the P600 powered continuously. The preamp is left in standby mode when it is not operating to prolong its tube life, and the P600 never complained.

Conclusion

Some may balk at the price of P600, but I can't imagine any audiophiles being anything but pleased with the sonic results -- unless they live in ideally powered homes that most of us can only dream of. I guess the P600's other negative is its enormity, which also becomes a moot point when its inconvenience is weighed against the improvement in sound it effects.

Short of nominating the folks at PS Audio for a Nobel Prize, I declare the P600 as the single most impressive piece of equipment that has passed through my system. I could say that the improvement to the sound of the system was as if I upgraded a component to one costing twice as much money, but the P600 did so much more than that. My system could hardly be considered to be the most opulent, so perhaps the P600's effects won’t be as noticeable in a higher-resolution system -- or perhaps would it make an even more noticeable difference. I would surely give the Power Plant P600 a try, though, because even with my power problems, I am happy at last.

...Tom Lyle
tom@soundstage.com

PS Audio Power Plant P600 Power Regenerator
Price:
$2195 USD with MultiWave.
Warranty: Three years parts and labor.

PS Audio
P.O. Box 2037
Avon, CO 81620
Phone: (877) 772-8340
Fax: (720) 406-8967

E-mail: sales@psaudio.com
Website: www.psaudio.com

[SoundStage!]All Contents
Copyright 2001 SoundStage!
All Rights Reserved